Content-type: text/html Downes.ca ~ Stephen's Web ~ Re: SCORM: Clarity or Calamity?

Stephen Downes

Knowledge, Learning, Community
Reaction to the article published last week, Scorm: Clarity or Calamity, ADL's Mark Oehlert lept to the defense (leading to catcalls of the SCORM Troopers being let loose). On Serious Instructional Technology and on trdev (a Yahoo group hidden behind a registration, but quoted in full here), Oehlert wrote, "The writer of the article has been fired, the print version of the magazine in which it appeared is out of business and the editor has allowed Thor Anderson of IMS, who is quoted at length in the article, to not only post an explanatory 'letter to the editor' but has also allowed him to go back into the article and edit hisquotes to resemble something more like the truth of his statements."

CRLFI contacted the editors of Online Learning Magazine, who replied:

CRLFStephen,
CRLFFor the record:

CRLF1) The writer is no longer with our company, but his departure has nothing whatsoever to do with the article. In fact, his employment with us was terminated prior to the issue being mailed.CRLF

CRLF2) The magazine in which it appeared has been incorporated into its 40-year-old sister publication, Training magazine. Given that e-learning is just another tool in the training/learning toolbox, it made no sense for us to continue publishing two separate products so we merged them into one (the one with the far superior brand image) that will continue to cover the entire market.CRLF

CRLF3) Any letters to the editor that we receive regarding Online Learning's last issue will be posted on www.onlinelearningmag.com since there will not be an opportunity for us to print them elsewhere (we cannot simply print them in the next issue of Training because Training's subscribers will have no earthly idea to which article they are referring.)CRLF

CRLF4) Finally, we did indeed allow Thor to alter his direct quotes. Typically, we would never have cause to do this. In a normal world, we would simply run his letter to the editor in the next issue of the magazine and hope that his letter would serve to clarify his quotes sufficiently for him. However, since there will be no "next" issue, I offered that we clean the quotes up before the article was posted.CRLF

CRLFI trust that this answers your questions.

CRLFTammy Galvin
CRLFExecutive Editor

Today: 6 Total: 96 [Direct link] [Share]

Image from the website


Stephen Downes Stephen Downes, Casselman, Canada
stephen@downes.ca

Copyright 2024
Last Updated: Nov 22, 2024 09:38 a.m.

Canadian Flag Creative Commons License.

Force:yes